Blocked Punt, Four Slye Field Goals: Titans Stun Colts 26-20 for First Win

Down 13-0 at halftime, Tennessee scored 20 unanswered points behind its defense and special teams to hand Robert Saleh his first win as Titans head coach.

Torch Newsroom · 2026-10-20

For five weeks the Titans had been the NFL's resident hard-luck story. On Sunday at Lucas Oil Stadium they finally flipped one — and they did it almost entirely without their offense. Tennessee beat the Colts 26-20, erasing a 13-0 halftime deficit with takeaways, a punt block and a perfect day from kicker Joey Slye, who went 4-for-4 from 29, 56, 49 and 44 yards.

A half of nothing, then the flip

The first half belonged to Indianapolis. Daniel Jones hit Mo Alie-Cox for a 1-yard touchdown and Spencer Shrader added field goals of 23 and 47 yards, the second set up by a Cam Ward interception. Tennessee managed just three first downs and 64 yards before the break.

The swing came immediately after halftime. Jeffery Simmons — who finished with two of Tennessee's six sacks — forced and recovered a Jonathan Taylor fumble on the first play of the third quarter, leading to Slye's first field goal. A Cor'Dale Flott interception set up Slye's 56-yarder, and the comeback was on.

Special teams win it

In the fourth quarter, Chimere Dike ripped off a 58-yard punt return to set up Ward's 8-yard touchdown to rookie Carnell Tate, tying it at 13. Then came the game's defining play: Tennessee blocked a Rigoberto Sanchez punt and Femi Oladejo returned it 14 yards for a touchdown and a 20-13 lead. Taylor answered with a 4-yard scoring run, but Slye's last two field goals — the 49-yarder with 2:03 left and a 44-yarder to close it — settled things, per the team's recap.

What it means

Tennessee is 1-5, and the manner of the win matters: it was Saleh's first as Titans head coach and, per the club, the franchise's 500th victory. Ward's line (11-of-22, 102 yards) says the offense remains a work in progress, but the defense forced three turnovers against one giveaway. For Indianapolis, now 2-4 per CBS Sports, the alarm is louder: Jones threw two interceptions, the Colts lost at home to a winless team, and the injury list grew: Sauce Gardner left with a calf injury and returner Anthony Gould entered concussion protocol and did not return.